Most high performers do not resign because they hate their job or earn too little; they resign because of their manager. Research shows that managers account for up to 70% of the variance in team engagement, and nearly 70% of employees are ready to leave if they face poor management. This article examines the managerial behaviours that inadvertently drive top talent away, the hidden costs involved, and how to retain exceptional staff before it is too late.
Have you ever experienced this? Your top-performing, most dependable team member suddenly walks in and hands in their resignation. Shocked, you ask why, and they simply reply, "I'd like to try something new," or "I've found a better opportunity."
You might assume it came down to compensation or simply a natural career transition. However, the unspoken truth at the moment of resignation is that they are often not walking away from the job—they are walking away from their manager.
To be frank, the notion that top talent leaves because of their managers is far from mere speculation; it is firmly supported by data. A 2026 survey revealed that nearly 70% of employees are prepared to quit due to a bad manager, and 42% of all resignations are preventable if managers take proactive action before it is too late.
The good news is that if the problem begins with the manager, the solution lies with the manager too. Today, let us explore which behaviours inadvertently drive top performers away and how you can retain them.
Is it true that "people do not leave jobs, they leave managers"?
Yes, it is, and there is robust evidence to support it. A manager is the single most influential factor shaping team engagement. Gallup research shows that managers account for up to 70% of the variance in team engagement. This means whether a team is energised or burnt out depends largely on their leader.
The reason is simple: the manager is the person employees interact with every day. They determine whether work feels rewarding or exhausting, whether there is room to grow or stagnate, and whether team members feel valued or overlooked.
A company may offer excellent benefits and a stylish office, but if immediate management makes each day frustrating, top performers with plenty of options will not hesitate to walk out.
The hidden cost of losing top talent
Many organisations view resignation merely as a matter of "finding a replacement". However, the actual cost is significantly higher. Replacing a manager or executive level role can cost up to 200% of their annual salary, while specialist roles cost around 80%, and frontline positions around 40%—and that does not account for the institutional knowledge lost along the way.
Even more damaging is the impact on the remaining team. When a top performer departs, their workload falls onto others, morale plummets, and a chain reaction can occur as colleagues begin to ask themselves, "Should I be looking elsewhere too?"
Yet, hidden within the numbers lies encouraging news: most resignations are preventable if managers spot the early warning signs and take timely action.
Which managerial behaviours drive top talent away unintentionally?
In most cases, managers are not deliberately unkind; they are simply "unaware". Behaviours that unintentionally push top talent away are often subtle, everyday habits that accumulate until capable individuals feel undervalued or stagnant. Common culprits include:
- Micromanaging every step — making high performers feel untrusted.
- Failing to offer praise or recognition — staying silent when work is outstanding, yet reacting sharply to the slightest mistake.
- Blocking pathways to growth — assigning repetitive tasks with no clear future in sight.
- Failing to provide meaningful feedback — leaving staff unsure of where they excel or how they can develop.
- Never asking about their future aspirations — failing to discuss their career goals and ambitions.
This last point is far more critical than it may seem. Nearly half of departing employees report that no manager or leader discussed their job satisfaction or future with them in the three months prior to leaving. A failure to communicate essentially leaves them to make their exit decision in silence.
Why do managers often realise it only when it is too late?
Because the decision to quit takes root in the mind long before the resignation letter is submitted. By the time an employee announces their departure, their decision is usually final. Studies show that most people resign shortly after starting their job search. In simple terms, once they begin sending out applications, it is often too late to retain them.
This is why waiting for staff to complain before addressing issues does not work. Top talent rarely complains; they stay silent and move on. Retaining high performers must therefore be a proactive effort rather than reactive firefighting.
To explore how a manager's reluctance to listen affects team dynamics, read our article: When Leaders Stop Listening.
How can managers retain top talent?
Retention comes from consistently making team members feel valued, supported in their growth, and genuinely heard—not just when they are on the brink of leaving. Retaining top talent does not require a large budget; it requires deliberate, weekly attention. Proven, evidence-based approaches include:
- Offer genuine praise and recognition. Employees who receive high-quality recognition are up to 45% less likely to leave over the next two years.
- Create opportunities to learn and grow. Staff supported in developing new skills are up to 47% less likely to seek other employment.
- Provide meaningful feedback consistently. Individuals who receive constructive, valuable feedback demonstrate significantly higher engagement.
- Hold regular one-to-one catch-ups. Enquire about their aspirations and experiences before they start looking elsewhere.
- Foster a safe space for open dialogue. When teams feel safe to voice concerns, managers can resolve issues before they escalate.
Here is a direct comparison between behaviours that drive top performers away and those that retain them:
| Behaviours that drive top talent away | Behaviours that retain top talent |
|---|---|
| Micromanaging every step | Trusting staff and granting autonomy |
| Staying silent despite excellent performance | Offering genuine praise and recognition |
| Assigning repetitive work with no future prospects | Opening opportunities to learn and grow |
| Never discussing their future | Regularly discussing growth paths |
| Finding out about issues only when they resign | Checking in before issues accumulate |
A Workplace Story: The Resignation Nobody Saw Coming
Let me share a common scenario I frequently encounter (drawn as an overview across several organisations, not based on any single individual).
Many managers share similar stories of being completely shocked when their top performer handed in their resignation. After all, they performed well, never complained, and never caused issues, so the manager assumed everything was fine. Only in hindsight did they realise they had never actually sat down to discuss where the team member wanted to grow, taking good work for granted and never offering praise.
After this experience, changing the approach by scheduling regular one-to-one check-ins, asking about their future, praising good work, and opening doors to new challenges transformed the team atmosphere. People stayed longer because they felt seen and cared for. The lesson is that top talent does not need a perfect manager; they need a manager who truly sees them.
Reflection Questions
- When was the last time you gave a team member genuine praise?
- Do you know the career aspirations and growth paths of each team member?
- Do you discuss the future with your team members "before" they consider leaving, or "after" they hand in their resignation?
- Is there a top performer in your team who has been unusually quiet lately?
- If your top performer resigned tomorrow, would you be surprised?
Next Action: Start Today
If you want to start retaining top talent, I recommend beginning with a small step this week: choose one team member you would least want to lose, and schedule a one-to-one check-in with no work agenda. Ask them, "How would you like to develop or grow this year?" and "How can I best support you?", and listen attentively.
With just one conversation, you send a clear signal that they are valued and seen. I believe managers who retain top talent are not necessarily those who offer the highest pay, but those who make their team feel: "Working here enables me to grow and feel genuinely valued." 💛
Related Courses
If your organisation is facing talent turnover and wants managers to change behaviours that drive people away, I recommend these courses:
- 👉 People Management Essentials for Line Managers – Lay the foundation for managers to motivate and retain top talent.
- 👉 People Management Essentials for Line Managers – Create psychological safety that empowers teams to speak up and choose to stay.
Or explore all our courses under Leadership and for organisations looking to build leaders systematically, discover our Leadership Development Program.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do top performers leave managers, not jobs?
Because managers are the people employees interact with daily and shape the work experience the most. Research by Gallup shows that managers account for up to 70% of the variance in team engagement. When managers make daily work draining, unappreciated, or stagnant, high performers with other options will readily resign, regardless of how good the job or the company is.
What managerial behaviours drive employees to resign?
Common behaviours include micromanaging, never offering praise or appreciation, blocking opportunities for growth, withholding meaningful feedback, and never discussing career progression. These habits rarely stem from malice, but accumulated daily, they make top talent feel undervalued and stagnant.
How can you tell if a top performer is about to resign?
Common warning signs include becoming unusually quiet, withdrawing participation, or showing signs of burnout in tasks they once embraced. However, many top performers do not complain openly, making early signs hard to spot. The most effective approach is regular one-to-one check-ins to understand their feelings and aspirations before they make the decision to leave.
What is the actual cost of losing top talent?
Much higher than anticipated. Replacing a managerial role costs approximately 200% of the annual salary, and specialist roles around 80%—not accounting for lost institutional knowledge, declining team morale, and the risk of a turnover contagion.
How can managers retain top talent?
By consistently ensuring they feel valued, given growth opportunities, and heard. This includes offering sincere praise, providing opportunities to learn new skills, giving meaningful feedback, holding one-to-one discussions about their future, and fostering a safe environment to speak up. Crucially, this must be done proactively, not after they have already decided to leave.
References
- Gallup – Managers Account for 70% of Variance in Employee Engagement (Source of the 70% statistic)
- Gallup – State of the Global Workplace: Global Employee Engagement Continues Decline (2026 report)
- Gallup data (42% preventable, 200% replacement cost) – Reported via Paycor and Yahoo Finance
- Gallup / Workhuman data (recognition reduces turnover by 45%, skill development by 47%) – Reported via Evolveup
